Tuesday, April 16, 2013

CL #9 - Knox Retrial May Force US Into Largely Uncharted Legal Territory



Amanda Knox, an American student studying in Italy, was convicted for the murder of her roommate back in 2007. On appeal, the court ruled that there was not enough evidence to uphold her conviction, and she ended up being released back to America in 2011. Earlier this year, the Italian court reviewed the case again and decided to retry it, which they can do since there is no double jeopardy in Italy. This ruling could force the US courts to enter legal territory that is pretty much uncharted. On one hand, the US has the right to protect its citizens under its own constitution, so double jeopardy would apply to her. On the other hand, the US has signed extradition treaties with Italy that would force her to be extradited to Italy if she is found guilty again. The treaty prohibits extradition if the new trial qualifies as double jeopardy, but the issue is whether or not double jeopardy would even apply. In Italy, appeals are not like they are in the US. While here the courts cannot consider the facts of the case or any new evidence, in Italy they can basically do the trial all over again. Some argue, therefore, that is is not double jeopardy because it is a completely new trial. If it's not double jeopardy, then the treaty would allow for Knox's extradition. The issue is very rare, but when it does come up, it doesn't tend to go in favor of the defendant, so Knox might be in trouble if she is found guilty again.

Source: http://www.reuters.com/article/2013/03/27/us-italy-knox-extradition-idUSBRE92Q01020130327

1 comment:

  1. Let the impending standoff ensue. What's more important: to uphold the principles of law your own system relies on or respect the sovereign authority of a nation who operates under a total different set of rules? Tough question to answer but I can't imagine the U.S. handing Knox over without scrutinizing the decision and Italy's procedural failings to the utmost extent.

    In the end, however, what's of higher value? I think the confidence of the U.S. people in their principles of justice is more important to uphold than respecting Italy's.

    ReplyDelete