Wednesday, March 13, 2013

IBL #4 - EU Promises Better Rights for Airline Passengers

image

The European Union has unveiled new proposals that will promise better rights and compensation for European travelers when their flights are delayed or canceled. The EU's transport chief, Siim Kallas said that "it's so important that passenger rights don't just exist on paper. We all need to be able to rely on them when it matters, at the airport, when things go wrong." The proposals are set to take effect in 2015, but the airlines are fighting them. They are concerned about the potential costs and burden on the industry. The proposals would require airlines to reroute passengers within a 12 hour time frame or find them an alternative solution to get to their destination. They will also be required to give passengers information about why their flight was canceled within 30 minutes of its scheduled departure. They will have to acknowledge complaints within a week, and respond within 2 months. In addition, passengers whose planes have been delayed will have the right to food and drink after 2 hours instead of 4. The airlines are definitely not in favor of these new proposals, and are likely to fight them all the way as they get turned into law, but it will certainly be a step up in the treatment of airline passengers if they are passed.

Source: http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424127887324077704578358142303934824.html

CL #6 - The Drone Strike Debate

Predator_drone

The President has the power to act speedily in response to an invasion of the country. It seems that the founding fathers made it this way in the Constitution because congress would be too slow in an emergency situation. Therefore, Congress was granted the power to declare war, and the President has the power to respond quickly to attacks on the country in order to separate the powers. Last week, Senator Rand Paul challenged the authority of the President on his drone strike policy. Does it violate the fifth amendment right of due process to strike down a U.S. citizen without even bringing criminal charges, let alone getting a guilty verdict and sentence? Senator Paul says that the fifth amendment applies to all Americans, and there are no exceptions. The White House and Attorney General have both assured that drone strikes would never be used against American citizens on U.S soil, but Senator Paul is not so sure that he believes it. I have a feeling that the debates over this issue are only beginning, and it will be interesting to see where they lead.

Source: http://blog.constitutioncenter.org/2013/03/constitution-check-could-the-president-legally-order-a-drone-strike-inside-the-u-s/

Sunday, March 3, 2013

IBL #3 - Swiss Public Votes to Curb CEO Pay

Ever since UBS, the biggest bank in Switzerland, had to be bailed out in 2008, the subject of CEO salaries has been a sore one among the Swiss public. They are currently earning as much as 13 million francs per year, which is 13.8 million US dollars. This week, the Swiss voters voted overwhelmingly to curb the salaries of their chief executive officers. Thomas Minder, the manager of a cosmetics company, started the initiative to cut CEO salaries back in 2006, and he has finally gotten a victory from it. Critics, however, are saying that the cuts will damage Switzerland's ability to serve as a base for big corporations. The government is still working out how they will translate the new rules into law, but they have been taking small steps. Just last week Parliament struck a deal to ban bonuses that are more twice the fixed pay, which will take effect next year. I think the US could definitely consider doing something similar, because our CEO pay rate is also much too high.

Source: http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2013-03-03/devil-is-in-the-details-as-swiss-vote-to-curb-ceo-pay.html

CL #5 - Sovereign States?


Justice Anthony Kennedy is currently taking a lot of flack for a comment he made during an oral argument regarding whether to strike down the Voting Rights Act. He was arguing against Section Five, which requires jurisdictions with a history of racially motivated voter suppression to get federal court permission before changing their voting laws. He then expressed his concern that this requirement violated the constitutional provision which declares each state to be an "independent sovereign". This language appeared in the Articles of Confederation, which preceded the US Constitution, but it does not appear in the Constitution itself, as it was intentionally removed. Article two of the Articles of Confederation was replaced with the 10th amendment to the Constitution, which delegates all powers not reserved to the federal government to the states, but certainly does not declare them "independent sovereigns". It is somewhat concerning that a justice on the Supreme Court would be misinterpreting the Constitution, considering that a big part of his job is knowing and understanding the document. It seems like our nation's leaders are finding more and more ways of using their own interpretations of what the founding fathers meant when they wrote the Constitution.

Source: http://consortiumnews.com/2013/03/03/perverting-the-constitution-for-power/

CL #4 - "Persons" vs. "People" in the Constitution

Alan Singer, a professor at Hofstra University, wrote an interesting article about the second amendment in which he examines the use of "persons" vs. the use of "people". In the midst of the heavy debate about the right to bear arms granted to the people in the Constitution, he throws out a textualist view of the intentions of the founding fathers. In the Constitution, the writers use the terms "person" and "persons" 22 times, but the term "people" only twice. In all amendments dealing with individual rights, the term "person" is always used. However, the second amendment deals with the rights of the "people" to keep and bear arms. According to Singer, the textualist view is that the founding fathers were referring to the nation as a whole, meaning that the nation has a right to defend itself. It's an interesting view, and it does make you wonder if the wording is intentional, or just an insignificant detail that gun control advocates are trying to make a big deal out of.

Source: http://www.huffingtonpost.com/alan-singer/gun-control-constitution_b_2657841.html